I appreciate all the help and advice, but perhaps I'm not being clear. Let me try again.
I _want_ to be subscribed to various _forums_ so that when I log into RS Talk, I can go to my User CP and see only the forums I care about (for example, I don't have an Ensim box, so I don't subscribe to those).
I _want_ to get an email notification when someone posts a reply to a thread that I either started or posted to.
I _do_not_want_ to get an email notification that there is a brand new thread in a forum I'm subscribed to.
This is exactly how it used to work for over a year (since I signed on to RS Talk) up until about 1 month ago. Suddenly, without me making _any_ changes to my account here, I started receiving email notifications for new threads in subscribed forums. I do not want this. I want to turn this off. There does not seem to be a way to do so, though.
I hope that helps clear things up. If it turns out that there really isn't a way to have it set up the way I described above, then so be it, but I figure it's worth persisting just in case I've overlooked something or an admin can take care of it for me.
Thanks!
-Danimal